Reflection One for Chato's Kitchen

Analysis Summary

This book can be considered problematic because it depicts stereotypes of Hispanic culture through the book's illustrations and text. It gives an unfair and stereotypical perspective that negatively reflects a culture based on characters actions and books illustrations.

Impact Assessment

I believe my focal student would enjoy the book “Chato’s Kitchen” however I also think it might confuse him on the fact that the book reflects many stereotypes of Hispanic culture. My student is proud of his culture and loves talking about his different experiences, however I would not want to expose him to the unfair and harsh stereotypes that have been associated with Mexican and Hispanic culture that are depicted in the book. On the other hand I think my student would enjoy seeing his culture being represented in a book however I believe there are more appropriate alternatives that my student can read and learn from.

Alternative Texts

Alternative books for making new friends:

• Meesha Makes Friends by Tom Percival
• Micheal Makes Friends at School by Martha Rustad

Alternative books that represent Mexcian Culture:

• Pepe and the Prade by Tracy Kelly
• Isabella and her Colores go to School by Alessandra Alesandri

Guiding Questions

1. How does the depiction of hispanic culture differ in both “Pepe and the Prade” and “Chato's Kitchen?”
2. How is the representation of diversity conveyed in “Pepe and the Prade?”
3. How can younger readers relate to “Pepe and the Parade?”